Employee who simulated sex act ‘was unfairly dismissed’

A training officer who simulated a sex act in the workplace has been awarded £14,870 compensation after an Employment Tribunal ruled that he had been unfairly dismissed.

The officer, Mr Robert Cuthbertson, trained engineering apprentices at a plant owned by Siemens plc.

The tribunal was told that strong language with sexual connotations was commonplace in the workplace and there were photographs of nude women on display in certain areas.

On one occasion, a parcel containing a sex toy meant for one of the occupational health advisers arrived without an address. Mr Cuthbertson lowered his trousers and simulated a sex act.

Despite his 39 years’ service with the company, he was dismissed for gross misconduct. The company said he had crossed a line between workplace banter and behaviour that was unacceptable.

The Employment Tribunal ruled that the dismissal was unfair.

Employment Judge Garnon said Mr Cuthbertson’s behaviour was no different to the kind of behaviour that the company had tolerated from him and others for several years. The difference was that on this occasion, the managing director had got to hear about it and junior managers felt that he would want “heads to roll,” even though there was no evidence that he did.

Not enough account had been taken of the fact that Mr Cuthbertson had admitted his actions immediately and described them as silly and childish.

Judge Garnon said: “I find the decision to dismiss is one which no reasonable employer could have taken and was well outside the band of reasonable responses. It follows I find the conduct in which the claimant (Mr Cuthbertson) engaged comes nowhere close to satisfying the definition of gross misconduct.

“The dismissal is therefore both wrongful and unfair.”

For more information about this article or any aspect of our employment services, please call Jeremy Garson on 020 8907 2000 or click here to email him and he will be delighted to help you (there is no charge for an initial telephone discussion).

Case featured:
Employee who simulated sex act ‘was unfairly dismissed’

Robert Cuthbertson and Siemens plc
Employment Tribunal North Shields
Employment Judge Garnon
2017

Show Buttons
Share On Youtube
Hide Buttons